What if you spend years investing in autism therapies, medications, school services, and treatments, and your child still struggles? How do you know whether all that time, money, and energy was worth it?
In Part 3 of the Future Planning series, Lisa Candera, The Autism Mom Coach, challenges one of the least useful questions autism parents ask themselves: “What if it’s all for nothing?”
One year after her autistic son underwent brain surgery for severe OCD, Lisa reflects on the difference between evaluating whether a treatment worked and whether the decision to pursue it was worthwhile. She explains why disappointing outcomes don’t automatically mean bad decisions and how to approach future interventions with clearer expectations.
In this episode, you’ll learn:
- Why measuring the value of autism therapies and interventions solely by their outcomes can lead you to overlook meaningful progress.
- How to establish realistic expectations based on your child’s current abilities, needs, and the specific goals of an intervention.
- The one question to ask before investing in another therapy, medication, or treatment, especially when there’s no guarantee it will work.
Before your next big decision, ask yourself: “Even if this doesn’t work out the way I’m hoping, would I still believe it was worth trying?”
Listen Here:
Transcript:
The Autism Mom Coach Podcast | Episode 222 | Future Planning Series, Part 3 of 4
I’ve spent three months living in a hotel so my autistic son could receive intensive treatment for his OCD. And a year ago, he underwent brain surgery for that same OCD.
Despite those significant interventions, Ben’s OCD still has a significant impact on his life.
So, was it all for nothing?
For me, the answer is no. And it will always be no.
After 19 years of autism parenting, I’ve come to believe that “What if it’s all for nothing?” is the most useless question an autism parent can ask themselves.
In today’s episode, I want to explain why and offer you an alternative.
Where This Question Comes From
Welcome back to The Autism Mom Coach podcast. You’re listening to Episode 222, part three of my series on future planning for autism moms.
Today’s topic came from a conversation I had with an autism mom who was relatively new to autism parenting. Her son was two and a half years old, and she was looking at everything she was already doing to support his development: therapies, appointments, money, time, and resources.
And she asked me something we’ve probably all asked ourselves at one point or another.
“What if it’s all for nothing?”
What if she spent years doing all of this and her child still struggled? What if all those therapies didn’t produce the progress she hoped for?
I knew exactly what she meant because I’d asked myself those same questions when Ben was little.
After Ben was diagnosed with autism at two, we had the option of pursuing early intervention services before he entered the school district and had an IEP.
But there were waiting lists, red tape, and delays. Ultimately, we weren’t receiving the support Ben needed to prepare for preschool.
And that was incredibly frustrating because everywhere I turned, I kept hearing how important early intervention was. The clock was ticking. We needed to do as much as possible, as quickly as possible.
Meanwhile, I felt like we were losing valuable time waiting for him to enter preschool.
So I started researching other options and eventually found a private provider where I could arrange the amount and type of therapy Ben needed, provided I could afford it.
Insurance wasn’t covering those services at the time, so this was a significant financial commitment.
And there were no guarantees.
Speech therapy couldn’t guarantee that Ben would develop verbal communication. The same uncertainty applied to occupational therapy, physical therapy, and behavioral interventions.
Every time I got another bill, part of me wondered, “What if this is all for nothing?”
And when Ben had another massive meltdown at therapy, resisted going, or had a meltdown on a random Saturday afternoon, I’d find myself asking that question again.
Was all this effort actually making a difference?
So I understood exactly where this mom was coming from.
And I was glad we were having this conversation so early in her autism parenting experience because I wanted to offer her a perspective that had taken me years to develop.
A way of making decisions based on the information available now, rather than constantly questioning whether those decisions would eventually pay off.
Here’s what I told her.
“What if it’s all for nothing?” is a terrible way to evaluate decisions you’ve already made or options you’re considering.
Because it conflates two very different things: how successful an intervention was and whether the decision to pursue it was worthwhile in the first place.
The Difference Between a Successful Treatment and a Worthwhile Decision
Let me give you an example from my own life.
A year ago, Ben underwent brain surgery to treat his severe OCD.
We knew going into that surgery that there was roughly a 60% chance of some improvement, and that the degree of improvement was uncertain. There was also a possibility that he would experience little to no benefit.
So we had to decide whether pursuing the surgery was worth it, knowing that it might not produce the outcome we hoped for.
For us, the answer was yes.
Ben had been resistant to medication and other treatments. We had exhausted the options available to us, and surgery represented another opportunity to potentially reduce the profound impact OCD was having on his life.
There was no world in which that option was available to us, we could reasonably pursue it, and we weren’t going to try.
Even if Ben experienced little to no improvement, knowing that we’d done everything reasonably possible to help him mattered to us.
That was part of why we made the decision.
And that brings me to why I think the question “Was it all for nothing?” is so unhelpful.
Why “All for Nothing” Is Such a Useless Question
Let’s start with something every experienced autism mom already knows.
You will work ten times harder than you think you should have to, for less progress than you think you should get.
That’s the rule, not the exception.
Think about something as simple as learning to use scissors.
I remember a client telling me about going to multiple craft stores and buying different types of scissors to help her child learn this skill because he was having difficulty with his grip.
All that research, time, money, and effort for a skill that many other children pick up without much difficulty.
That’s the reality of autism parenting.
We’re going to work harder, try different approaches, and sometimes feel like we’re throwing spaghetti against the wall to see what sticks.
I’ve experienced this with Ben in so many ways.
I can spend years coaching and supporting him around a particular skill or way of thinking, only to have one of his friends suggest something similar and suddenly he’s willing to try it.
Would I have predicted that? Absolutely not.
But does that mean all the coaching and support I provided beforehand was worthless?
No. I believe that work helped build a foundation that eventually allowed him to adapt and apply something when he was ready.
And that’s the problem with measuring the value of our efforts solely against the outcome.
There’s often an enormous difference between the effort we invest and the results we see.
When we ask whether it was all for nothing, we’re measuring years of time, money, and energy against an outcome we may have very little control over.
And we turn everything into an all-or-nothing proposition.
Either your child develops speech or the speech therapy was a waste.
Either the meltdowns stop or the behavioral intervention didn’t work.
Either your child eventually lives independently or all those years teaching life skills were for nothing.
When we evaluate things this way, we overlook meaningful progress because we’re focused on whether we’ve reached the ultimate outcome.
We may not even stop to consider whether that outcome was realistic in the first place, or whether our expected timeframe made sense.
And then we carry that same thinking into future decisions.
We start looking for some assurance that the next therapy, medication, or treatment will finally produce the result we’re hoping for.
But as we’ve talked about throughout this series, we don’t get those guarantees.
Get Clear on Why You’re Making the Investment
Instead of asking whether it could all be for nothing, I want you to get clear on why you’re investing your time, energy, and resources in the first place.
What are you hoping to accomplish, and what can you realistically expect?
This goes back to the first two episodes of this series.
In Episode 220, we talked about getting clear on the decision you’re making, identifying your non-negotiables, and knowing when to reassess.
In Episode 221, we talked about establishing your child’s baseline, identifying priorities, and setting realistic expectations based on the child in front of you.
Those same principles apply here.
Let’s say your child’s psychiatrist recommends trying a new medication.
And you’re thinking, “What if we go through another medication trial and it doesn’t work?”
Well, what are you hoping to accomplish?
If you’re looking for a magic solution that will eliminate every meltdown, obsessive thought, or aggressive episode, that’s probably not a realistic expectation.
But if you’re looking for something that might reduce the severity of your child’s symptoms and improve their daily functioning and quality of life, that’s something you can evaluate.
Let’s say your child is having several aggressive episodes a week, and you and the psychiatrist decide to try a medication with the goal of reducing their frequency or intensity.
Maybe the medication helps significantly. Maybe you see modest improvement. Maybe it causes side effects that outweigh the benefits. Or maybe it doesn’t help at all.
If it doesn’t work, you now have information about how your child responded to that medication.
And that’s useful information when you’re deciding what to do next.
I’ve been through this myself, and so have several of my clients.
We’ve had our children admitted for inpatient psychiatric treatment, where medication changes can sometimes be made and monitored more quickly. That can involve discontinuing previous medications and introducing new ones.
These decisions are informed by clinical experience, evaluations, and available evidence. But there’s still uncertainty about how a particular child will respond to a medication or combination of medications.
That’s especially true when you’re dealing with autism alongside conditions like OCD, anxiety, or other complex psychiatric challenges.
You can make a thoughtful, informed treatment decision and still discover that the medication doesn’t produce the benefit you hoped for.
That outcome doesn’t automatically mean the decision to try it was all for nothing.
Stop Using Hindsight Against Yourself
There’s another reason I think this question is so damaging.
It undermines your ability to make decisions and trust yourself.
Because when you keep asking, “What if it’s all for nothing?” you’re leaving open the possibility that years from now, you’re going to look back and criticize yourself for a decision you made with the information you had at the time.
Maybe you’ll learn something later that would have changed your decision. Maybe you’ll look back and wish you’d chosen differently.
But you couldn’t have known those things when you made the original decision.
And if you’re constantly anticipating that future version of yourself who will question everything you did, making decisions today becomes much harder.
I’ve made a deliberate decision that I’m not going to spend my time doing that.
When I catch myself revisiting past decisions simply to find fault with them, I stop.
Parenting Ben already requires an enormous investment of my time, energy, and attention.
I need those resources for the decisions I’m making today and the challenges we’re dealing with now.
Going back through old decisions and finding new reasons to criticize myself doesn’t help Ben.
And it doesn’t help me make the next decision.
So instead of leaving open the possibility that you’ll spend the next five, ten, or fifteen years questioning whether a decision was worthwhile, consider deciding now that you’re not going to evaluate your choices that way.
Get clear about the decision you’re making. Understand why you’re making it and what you’re realistically hoping to accomplish.
Make the best decision you can with the information available to you.
And when you have new information, use it.
Because there is no magic pill or guaranteed path through autism parenting.
There’s what you’re trying, what works, what doesn’t work, what you learn, and what you do next.
And that’s where I want you to put your attention.
Next week, in the final episode of this series, we’re going to talk about the things you can be doing right now to prepare for your autistic child’s future.
Take care.